I recently considered
“going Amish.”
Not the way you may be thinking.
An agent I know asked me to consider writing a novel with an
Amish community as the setting.
“Amish sells,” she told me.
Why? Apparently, people are living such complicated, crazy
lives these days, they look to the Plain people and the simple life depicted in
Amish books for escape.
“But I’m not Amish,” I said. “I’ve visited the Amish
community in Holmes County, Ohio. It’s only a few hours from where I live. But
my only other experience with the Amish is through a research study I read in
graduate school.”
“You’re more than qualified,” she assured me. “I can sell
anything Amish.”
I was not convinced. I had a few ideas for my next book, but
“anything Amish” was not among them. Still, I am not one to say no without a
bit of thought and research.
My mother enjoys Amish stories so I prevailed on her to loan
me a few of her books to read. Suffice it to say there is Amish and there is
Amish. Beverly Lewis and Wanda Brunstetter probably have the best Amish books
I’ve read so far.
I read a couple of others that lacked authenticity. They
seemed to have taken an existing story and force fit it into a buggy. Authenticity
is important. Throwing in a smattering of Pennsylvania Dutch and a quilt here
and there won’t cut it.
Finding Authenticity
I decided to dig out the ethnography (eth-naw'-graf-ee) I read in
graduate school titled Children in Amish
Society: Socialization and Community Education. It was written by John
Hostetler, a man born into an Old Order Amish family.
Good ethnographic research relies on multiple pieces of
evidence to accurately portray a particular culture. I have read ethnographies
describing deaf culture, the culture of teens in a parochial school setting,
and the Navajo culture among others. Ethnographies are not merely stories of a
culture or one person’s perception. They rely on careful observation and
accurate field notes, interviewing “informants” (people within the culture being
studied), collecting artifacts, conducting surveys and so forth.
I share this because I believe a good ethnography is a
reliable resource for understanding a culture and a great resource for writers
–one that is often overlooked by new writers.
Central to any cultural group is their language, food,
religion, and music. An ethnography following an anthropological model will
examine these areas as it describes the people, their values and beliefs. It
will give accurate details describing the rituals and events important to
shaping their cultural norms and it will describe how the geographic location
supports the group’s way of life.
Finding an
Ethnography
There are over 800 ethnographies listed on Goodreads alone. I
am not convinced they are all rigorous in the research method used, but still
believe a writer could study these to inform his or her writing. Personally, I
am drawn to university libraries housing large collections of ethnographic research.
Summing It Up
To make my decision
about “going Amish” I read several Amish novels. I pulled out a couple of
ethnographies written to explain Amish culture. I prayed about it.